德国氢能赛道.pdf

《德国氢能赛道.pdf》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《德国氢能赛道.pdf（42页珍藏版）》请在得力文库 - 分享文档赚钱的网站上搜索。

1、11Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterMarch 2023www.corporateeurope.org2Author:Pia EberhardtEdited by:Ann DohertyCoordinated by:Beln BalanyDesign and graphics by:Gerard Casadevall BachThanks to:Andy Gheorghiu,Lasse Thiele,Jenn

2、y Simon,Katharine Ainger and all interview partners for valuable insights and comments.Published by:Corporate Europe ObservatoryMarch 2023,BrusselsContents of this report may be quoted orreproduced for noncommercial purpose,provided that the source of information is acknowledged.Corporate Europe Obs

3、ervatory(CEO)is aresearch and campaign group working toexpose and challenge the disproportionateinfluence that corporations and theirlobbyists exert over EU policy-making.CEOworks in close alliance with public interestgroups and social movements in andoutside of Europe to develop alternatives tothe

4、dominance of corporate power.www.corporateeurope.org3Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterExecutive summaryFor years,Germany has hyped hydrogen as the centrepiece of a climate-neutral economy and the EU has welcomed this allege

5、d miracle gas with open arms.Germanys influential role in setting the EUs agenda has contributed to hydrogen being now at the core of EU climate and industrial policies,and Brussels plans to spend billions in public subsidies to spur Europes hydrogen sector.This hype ignores several dirty facts.Firs

6、t,99 per cent of todays globally produced hydro-gen is grey hydrogen made from fossil fuels,with annual CO2 emissions exceeding those of the entire country of Germany.Second,fossil-based blue hydrogen,which is being promoted as a low-carbon alternative,has a climate footprint that is nearly as bad w

7、hen its total emissions are taken into account.Finally,even green hydrogen,which is consid-ered carbon free but accounted for only 0.04 per cent of global hydrogen production in 2021,comes with serious challenges and risks.It is energy inefficient,behaves as a potent indirect greenhouse gas,and prod

8、uction on a large scale requires vast amounts of land,water and renewable energy.Its production can fuel green grabbing the appropriation of land and resources for environmental ends.An inflated demand for hydrogen is also being used as a Trojan horse to prolong the use of fossil fuels.More and more

9、 experts are thus warning that an energy economy focused on hydrogen will actually increase emissions.The German Advisory Council on the Environment,for example,an expert advisory body of the German government,has stated that hydrogen“cannot play an overarching role”in solving the climate crisis.Why

10、 then does hydrogen enjoy such a privileged position in German and EU politics today?Who is driving the German hydrogen craze,and who is benefitting from it?And what are the likely impacts for prospective green hydrogen export countries?These are the questions addressed in this report.Carlos Ardana4

11、Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterKey findings Behind Germanys hydrogen dash lies a broad network of companies,industry associations and consultancies.More than 100 German businesses have been identi-fied as key players alon

12、g the value chain for green hydrogen.Many of them are from or have ties to the fossil fuel and other polluting industries,and they are jumping on the hydrogen bandwagon to lock in harmful infrastructure as well as production and con-sumption models.Germanys hydrogen lobby employs hundreds of lobbyis

13、ts and spends millions on influencing German politics.Chemical giant BASF,for example,a large user and producer of fossil hydrogen,had a lobby budget of 3.8 million in 2021 and currently employs 24 lobbyists.Germanys largest energy lobby group BDEW,whose member companies are responsible for 90 perce

14、nt of fossil gas sales in Germany and who are betting on hydrogen to stay in business,has 51 lobbyists and a lobby budget of 7.1 million in 2021.Such lobby power allows the hydrogen industry to follow and influence complex regulatory processes and to secure lobby meetings with key decision makers.Li

15、ke past German governments,the current coalition of Social Democrats,Greens and Liberals grants privileged access to the gas lobby,a driving force behind the hydrogen hype.From December 2021 to September 2022,high-ranking government officials met with gas lobbyists on average once a day.These meetin

16、gs included several behind-closed-door conversations about hydrogen with lobbyists from fossil fuel majors like RWE,Equinor and Wintershall Dea as well as engineering giants like Siemens Energy(which manufactures gas pipeline components and electrolyser plants to produce green hydrogen)and MAN Energ

17、y Solutions(a subsidiary of car behemoth Volkswagen,which produces electrolyser components and engines for the automobiles and ships that it plans to fuel with hydrogen).The hydrogen lobby has co-drafted the German H2Global public funding scheme.This scheme arose from the Business Alliance for Energ

18、y,an industry-only fo-rum created by the German Ministry for Economic Development and Cooperation that paves the way for the early involvement of industry in the Ministrys hydrogen strategy.The Hydrogen and Fuel-Cell Association(DWV),an influential lobby group in the hydro-gen sector,seems to have p

19、layed a key role in drafting the concept for H2Global.The German government has allocated more than 4 billion(following an initial endowment of 900 million)to the funding scheme to spur green hydrogen exports to Germany.The German governments main hydrogen advisory body,the National Hydrogen Council

20、,is dominated by corporate lobbyists who steer Germanys hydrogen policy in the interest of their profits.These 25 experts include representatives from 15 companies from across the hydrogen supply chain:gas company Linde,grid operator Open Grid Europe,car manufacturer Daimler Truck,chemicals producer

21、 Covestro,and so on.The two environmental NGOs on the Council can always be overruled,and global justice groups are completely absent from the body despite Germanys dependence on hydro-gen imports.Germanys recent shift to blue hydrogen has been one of the lobbys biggest wins.Unlike Germanys 2020 hyd

22、rogen strategy,the updated version(which was being finalised at the time of writing),explicitly foresees the use and public funding of fos-sil-derived blue hydrogen.Projects to import blue hydrogen and its derivatives are already in the planning,for example with both Norway and the United Arab Emira

23、tes.5Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterAs its carbon balance can be worse than the traditional burning of coal,oil and gas,the scaling up of blue hydrogen risks driving up emissions.Some experts warn that invest-ments in blu

24、e hydrogen are worse than inaction on climate change,not least because they lock in the fossil fuel economy.Germany has established hydrogen alliances and partnerships with at least 26 potential export countries,many of them in the Global South.Berlin plans to cover two-thirds of its future green hy

25、drogen demand with imports and is set to become Europes biggest importer of the gas,with an estimated 60 to 70 per cent share of the future EU/UK import demand.German corporations are keen participants in this global quest,and accom-pany ministers whenever they go on hydrogen missions.German-backed

26、green hydrogen projects abroad follow colonial patterns.Resources are appropriated while negative impacts like ecological damage and energy scarcity are con-veniently outsourced.Conflicts over land and water use are already becoming apparent and could intensify over the next years.There are also con

27、cerns about the livelihoods of fishing communities as a result of mega ports and other export infrastructure,as well as pollution from the waste of the desalination plants that are needed to obtain water for green hydro-gen production in arid regions.A shocking example of human rights violations con

28、nected with green hydrogen projects is Saudi Arabias planned megacity Neom,where Thyssenkrupp will install a huge electrolyser to produce hydrogen for export.Ancient tribes have been forcibly evicted from their land to make way for Neom.Several protestors have been sentenced to death because of thei

29、r resistance to the eviction,and one of them was shot dead by security forces in April 2020.Nonetheless,the 2021 German-Saudi Arabia hydrogen cooperation seeks to imple-ment joint projects in Neom.Such cooperations risk the reproduction and legitimisation of authoritarian regimes in the name of sust

30、ainability.Hydrogen projects in the Global South tend to be centralised mega projects and lack civic participation.A mapping of 27 mostly African countries could not identify a single hydrogen project in which the community was consulted prior to the decision to proceed with the project.A small grou

31、p of political and economic elite is likely to profit from these top-down processes.While the German state-industrial complex has lobbied to delay the EUs sustain-ability criteria for green hydrogen,it has developed nice-sounding standards to create acceptance for green hydrogen projects abroad.But

32、these standards apply only to a few select sites,and they ignore key issues such as communities prior and informed consent.Community organisers have criticised the prospect of green enclave projects that will not become an integral part of their economies due to the lack of local ownership.This repo

33、rt concludes that the looming hydrogen colonialism in the EU and Germany fails to deliver on global justice and energy democracy concerns as much as it fails to deliver on its key promise:to help tackle the climate crisis.Instead,there is a real risk that the hydrogen race will delay action to struc

34、turally decarbonise the economy:for example,increasing the energy efficiency of buildings(rather than heating homes inefficiently with hydrogen),transitioning to agroecological farming(rather than just greening synthetic fertilisers)and reducing traffic(instead of wasting energy on hydrogen-powered

35、cars).It is time that social justice and climate movements stand up against project hydrogen and the damage it will likely cause to communities and the planet.6ContentsExecutive summary 3Introduction 7Beware the hype:hydrogens dirty truths 9Meet Germanys hydrogen lobby 13Letting polluters run the hy

36、drogen show 18Not a bridge,but the end point?Germanys shift towards blue hydrogen 22The Global Souths looming green hydrogen curse 24Conclusion 33Endnotes34Introduction7Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterIt was yet another hu

37、man rights crackdown in Saudi Arabia.In autumn 2022,three men were sentenced to death;two others had been given 50-year prison sentences.All they had done was to protest their eviction from their homes to make way for Neom,the regimess planned megacity.“These shocking sentences.show the Saudi author

38、ities callous disregard for human rights,and the cruel measures they are prepared to take,”commented human rights group ALQST.1 The group had long called on businesses in-volved in Neom to either use their leverage with the Saudi authorities to quash the unjust verdicts or to withdraw from the proje

39、ct.2In September 2022,around the time of the verdicts,representatives of one German corpo-ration active in Neom had indeed travelled to Saudi Arabia.Top bosses from engineering giant Thyssenkrupp,which will install an electrolyser to produce hydrogen in the mega-city,were part of a business delegati

40、on accompanying German Chancellor Olaf Scholz to the Gulf.The goal of this“energy shopping tour,”3 as the trip was framed by the Left oppo-sition party,was to grant German industry access to hydrogen projects in Saudi Arabia as well as to hydrogen exports leaving the country.The grim human rights si

41、tuation appar-ently did not dampen spirits,and the German delegations mission was accomplished.Welcome to Germanys brave new hydrogen world.How Germany shapes this new hydrogen world will have serious repercussions on the EU level.Germanys strategy on this trendy gas“has had the strongest influence

42、on hydrogen discussions in Brussels,”says a former researcher from climate think tank E3G.4 Again and again,the German government in close cooperation with the pro-hydrogen fossil fuel lobby has used its influence to push hydrogen on the EU level,for example,during the German Presidency of the EU Co

43、uncil in 2020.5As a result,hydrogen has become a cornerstone of EU policies and the EU plans to spend billions in public subsidies to spur its hydrogen sector.The blocs REPowerEU plan set the EUs 2030 targets for green hydrogen to 20 million tonnes,with one half to be produced at home and the other

44、half imported.6 Compare that with the less than 0.04 million tonnes of green hydrogen that were produced globally in 20217 and you get an idea of how impossibly high that target is.The EU also plans to scale up hydrogen infrastructure,and the gas industry is lobbying for a Hydrogen Backbone that wou

45、ld include 53,000 kilome-tres of hydrogen pipelines partly retrofitted fossil gas infrastructure and partly new by 2040.8 Again,this would be a massive ramp up from the mere 2,000 kilometres of pipe-lines that are currently able to carry hydrogen in Europe.98Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate

46、 perpetuation of fossil fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterGermanys hydrogen strategy will also have impacts on global supply chains and trade routes.While the government is investing heavily to produce green hydrogen at home,it plans to cover two-thirds of its future demand for the gas wi

47、th imports.In fact,Germany is set to become Europes biggest hydrogen importer,with an estimated share of 60 to 70 per cent of the future combined EU/UK import demand.10 This explains why German politicians have been touring the globe to sign deals with potential export countries over the past months

48、.This phenomenon is reason enough for Corporate Europe Observatory to unpack the German dash for hydrogen.Who is driving it and who is benefitting from it?How green is Germanys hydrogen economy?What are the likely socio-economic and ecological impacts in prospective green hydrogen export countries,m

49、any of which are in the Global South?These are some of the questions addressed in this briefing.But let us start with some basics:the difference between the hype and reality of hydrogen.Martin AdamsBeware the hype:hydrogens dirty truths9Germanys great hydrogen raceThe corporate perpetuation of fossi

50、l fuels,energy colonialism and climate disasterGermany and the EU have been hyping hydrogen for years,promoting it as the centrepiece of a climate-neutral economy.Think for example about steel production,which could become less polluting if hydrogen was burned instead of coal,or imagine decarbonisin